Working with the End User in the Prototype Model

Developing software presents a key hurdle: ensuring that the end product aligns with the product owner’s vision. Obstacles like misinterpretations or changing priorities can make this a daunting task. When the intended results do not match the original vision, it can lead to an unsatisfactory outcome for everyone involved.

Traditional software development techniques, like the Waterfall approach, often result in less input from both the product owner and the end user. After initial analysis of requirements, development commences with minimal communication until the final product is ready to be rolled out.

Iterative models acknowledge the challenge of aligning the product owner’s vision with the end product and place value on incorporating their input throughout the project. Recognising that software development isn’t always a straightforward process, regular feedback helps to enhance the work and create a more efficient solution in the long run.

Introducing the Prototype Model

The prototype model involves creating an initial version of the product, testing it, and then making additional improvements until the final product meets the necessary standards. This prototype serves as the foundation for the end product, and can be considered a software development process.

Although there are several different prototyping techniques to choose from, they all tend to follow a similar pattern:

  1. The project requirements are first specified in as much detail as possible. The team then collaborates with the product owner and end users to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the project.
  2. The development team convenes to discuss the requirements and create a rough outline of the prototype’s structure.
  3. The initial prototype for the project has been finished. It is a simple, streamlined version of the system that approximates the development team’s goal.
  4. One subset of the user base is given access to the prototype, and their feedback, both favourable and not, is gathered and analysed by the development team.
  5. Based on the feedback received, the team determines how to address the comments, which could range from adding new features to eliminating existing ones.
  6. The prototype is adjusted accordingly, and a second version is created.
  7. Steps 3 through 6 are repeated as often as necessary before the users are satisfied with the prototype.
  8. The final product is then developed utilizing the prototype as a guide.
  9. The product is meticulously evaluated, deployed, and maintained.

Prototypes are built using quick techniques and temporary code. The purpose is not to produce software that is completely operational and free of bugs (which comes later on). Instead, a prototype is a representation, akin to a concept drawing for a piece of art or a model for a building.

A prototype is similar to a sandbox playground; it’s a space for exploration and experimentation, where all project stakeholders can comfortably explore ideas without the fear of making any final judgments.

Before delving into the user’s role in greater depth, it’s crucial to remember that prototypes can be an invaluable resource, though they may also have specific restrictions.

Indeed, prototypes may necessitate a significant amount of time to create, and not every project can accommodate such an extended development timeframe. When getting a product to market promptly is critical, agile methodologies have been proved to be the most dependable method.

A User Guide to Prototyping

Users play a pivotal role in the prototyping process. Their feedback is invaluable in assisting developers in designing a successful final product. The user’s role is simple: engage with the prototype, ask questions, provide feedback, and repeat the process when a new prototype becomes available.

Nevertheless, the process may be obstructed by users who exceed their limits or do not grasp the built-in constraints of the prototyping model. The following are some recommendations.

User Training

It’s wise for developers to avoid designing a prototype in isolation. Producing supporting documentation for the prototype, including its purpose, the underlying technologies, expected user feedback, and potential issues encountered, is strongly suggested. This will assist in managing user expectations.

Users, kindly go through the supporting documents and remember that the prototype is not the final product. Certain features that you may find unappealing or displeasing may only be a temporary solution until the next version.

Looking at a fundamental tool for the first time can be disheartening, but it’s crucial to remember that this is just the start of a lengthy process. For instance, your development team may present their initial prototype as an Excel sheet, but this does not imply that the final product will look the same as this.

If you’re unsure, request the person showing you around the prototype to advise you on what you should concentrate on.

Be Mindful of the Prototype Type You Are Testing

Understanding the dissimilarities between throwaway and incremental prototypes are critical because there isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach to prototype testing. Knowing these differences can enhance testing effectiveness.

Throwaway prototypes: Proof of concept prototypes are rapidly built and discarded quickly as well. They are intended to showcase a specific feature or an initial strategy for the project.

Feedback on throwaways ought to concentrate on the precise features being tested. Avoid discussing any improvements that are outside the prototype’s intended scope, as this may result in the prototype being dismissed when analysing the feedback.

Evolutionary prototypes: Prototyping is a continuous process where the same prototype is refined through feedback. Since all parties are working from the same prototype, both time and effort are saved. This is the most commonly used type of prototyping.

Users, please evaluate not just the prototype itself but also the improvements it has undergone with each iteration. Identify where your previous feedback has been incorporated into the project and verify that it meets your requirements.

Incremental Prototyping breaks down the final product into several subsystems with a prototype designed for each. After all prototypes have been thoroughly tested and refined, they are merged to form the final product.

As a prototype user, your primary responsibility is to give feedback on the main feature you are testing. If you are uncertain why something is missing, please consult the documents or contact the developer. It’s probable that what you were expecting is actually part of another system.

Use a Prototype to Articulate Ideas Effectually

Prototypes offer an efficient means of communication between developers and consumers, with the adage “A picture is worth a thousand words” coming to mind. In this context, prototypes act as a link between an idea and its actual implementation.

In software development, using a prototype model is a valuable approach that acknowledges user engagement’s significance. Keeping users up-to-date during the development process enhances efficiency and yields a better final product.

Join the Top 1% of Remote Developers and Designers

Works connects the top 1% of remote developers and designers with the leading brands and startups around the world. We focus on sophisticated, challenging tier-one projects which require highly skilled talent and problem solvers.
seasoned project manager reviewing remote software engineer's progress on software development project, hired from Works blog.join_marketplace.your_wayexperienced remote UI / UX designer working remotely at home while working on UI / UX & product design projects on Works blog.join_marketplace.freelance_jobs