Scrum Master vs. Agile Coach: Why Both Are Required for Successful Transformations

The undertaking of an agile transformation is a complex process that necessitates a significant change in an individual’s mindset, mindset, and actions. Regrettably, companies frequently overlook the difficulty of these changes and don’t adequately prepare or allocate resources, resulting in an unsuccessful transition.

Organizations that are undergoing an Agile transformation may benefit from the assistance of a seasoned Agile coach. The position of an Agile coach necessitates a diverse range of skills, including extensive knowledge of Agile processes and expertise in directing and assisting teams and individuals throughout the transformation. The Agile coach is responsible for aiding in the definition and refinement of Agile procedures within the organization while also providing advice and assistance when barriers arise. In doing so, the coach can help guarantee a smooth and effective transition to organizational agility.

I recently engaged in a fascinating conversation with a hiring manager from a significant insurance company. Our discussion centred around the notion that agile coaches bear responsibility for both team performance and operational agility. When asked if a team’s failure is suggestive of ineffective coaching, I suggested that, while that may be the case in some instances, it is primarily not. I argued that the Scrum Master should be held accountable for the team’s success, rather than simply placing responsibility on the coach. By doing so, teams can avoid being responsible for their achievements while disregarding the coach’s involvement in creating organizational efficiency.

In my opinion, outstanding Agile coaches produce excellent Scrum Masters, who, in turn, create high-performing Agile teams.

The implementation of Scrum necessitates time and practice

Scrum is a prevalent Agile methodology, which is both straightforward to comprehend and difficult to master. The Scrum framework’s extensive principles and practices are outlined in the 14-page Scrum Guide, which offers an easy-to-understand manual. Nevertheless, mastering the Scrum methodology necessitates more than simply reading the Scrum Guide. The ability to quickly adjust to intricate and rapidly changing scenarios requires time, experience, and a willingness to let go of any deep-rooted behaviours that are counter-productive.

Organizations frequently attempt to achieve expert-level outcomes with minimal preparation when making the switch to Agile, by forming teams, providing basic training, and expecting them to implement agility competently. This is similar to anticipating a beginner tennis player to win against Roger Federer after only one day of training with him. Attempting to achieve such outcomes without proper guidance and support is risky and may give the impression that Agile is just another fleeting trend. It is important to recognise that Scrum necessitates individuals to engage in fresh ways of thinking and behaving, which is almost impossible without dedicated assistance. Teaching the Scrum Guide and expecting professional-level outcomes is a mistake, which is why the association between an Agile coach and a Scrum Master is so crucial. The two collaborate to assist teams to adopt Agile successfully, paving the way for high levels of performance.

Duties and Positions

The Agile Coach

Despite the fact that the Scrum Guide does not yet officially recognise the role of an Agile Coach, industry professionals created the position with the goal of better preparing teams for success. However, numerous organizations do not consider a coach to be a crucial part of an Agile transformation, or even consider it to be interchangeable with the Scrum Master position. Although there are similarities in the necessary skill sets for each role, an Agile Coach’s expertise and responsibilities exceed those of a Scrum Master. Essentially, an Agile Coach is a highly trained Scrum Master who works to enhance overall agility across the entire organization, with a comprehensive view of progress, and is capable of supporting several teams while also collaborating with leadership.

A proficient Agile coach serves as a model for practice discipline and champions for perpetual education. This coach leads by example, displaying servitude and comprehending the distinctions between mentoring, training, and facilitation, as well as comprehending the ideal instances to use each technique. Considerably, the coach guides the team to successful and imaginative solutions without needing to give extensive directions or fostering dependence on the coach. This procedure necessitates a significant amount of time, hard work, knowledge, and patience, but the benefits are tremendous.

The daily obligations of an Agile coach encompass the following:

  • Establishing best practices and conveying the Agile methodology
  • Instructing teams on how to employ Agile tools and strategies
  • Helping with primary retrospectives and stand-ups
  • Supervising organisational advancement and overcoming any hindrances
  • Augmenting leadership and stakeholder endorsement
  • Formulating and preserving standards
  • Offering guidance to corporate leaders as they shift to an Agile outlook

Scrum Master Role

The duties of the Scrum Master resemble those of an Agile Coach to some extent, and it is conceivable that if companies had a sufficient number of Scrum Masters who were competent and experienced in the Scrum methodology, there would be less of a demand for an Agile Coach. Sadly, many Scrum Masters are previous Project Managers who may not possess an expert comprehension of the Scrum framework and thus necessitate extra coaching from an Agile Coach.

The domain of a Scrum Master is comparatively narrower than that of an Agile Coach, and they typically concentrate on a single team. It is crucial for Scrum Masters to be acquainted with the strengths and weaknesses of the team, possible challenges, and growth prospects as they are deeply intertwined with the team. A proficient Scrum Master must utilise this knowledge to boost the team’s efficiency by implementing strategies and processes that are tailored to the team. The Scrum Master should possess an ardent zeal for leading the team towards continuous advancement. If the Scrum Master neglects the team’s requirements, then the team and its members may lose out on opportunities for growth.

The daily tasks of a Scrum Master encompass:

  • Education on Scrum theory and practices.
  • Aiding people in enhancing their knowledge and proficiencies in Agile.
  • Arranging and guiding constructive and efficacious meetings and Agile ceremonies.
  • Enabling efficient team communication.
  • Helping with sprint planning and backlog management for the team.
  • Supervising and enhancing team performance.
  • Providing the team with the capacity to deliver high-value increments while fulfilling commitments.

The Connection between Scrum Master and Agile Coach

I firmly recommend utilising the potency of Agile coaches to build and strengthen the competencies of Scrum Masters. This methodology is aligned with Scrum values and Agile principles, and I have consistently advocated that coaches should function as advisors rather than employees. Ideally, a proficient Agile coach would eventually become dispensable as the Scrum Masters acquire the necessary knowledge and skills. Once sufficient time has passed and the project’s momentum has been established, a Community of Practice consisting of adept Scrum Masters can take on the coaching role. If circumstances demand the assistance of a coach, then one can be recruited on an as-needed basis.

Here are some strategies to implement this approach, optimise both positions, and aid teams in achieving maximum efficiency:

  • Agile coaches should bolster education, proffer direction, and advocate for professional growth for Scrum Masters.
  • As Scrum Masters, it is vital to guarantee that we possess the requisite access and the mandate to accomplish tasks that are delegated to our teams. We need to concentrate on devising growth plans that are customised to the precise requirements of our teams to optimise their performance.
  • Scrum Masters should aspire to advance and cultivate Agile coaching skills and proficiency.

The Coach’s Duty to Foster Organisational and Team Development

Leaders who anticipate Agile coaches to take charge and compel teams forward may unwittingly be harming their organisations. It is more advantageous to establish empowered teams that can achieve their objectives without requiring extensive Agile coaching. If team members start to rely on the coach and become apprehensive about what might occur if the coach departs, this may indicate a larger concern. It is plausible that coaching has resulted in teams becoming too reliant, or that the teams have placed more confidence in the coach rather than their Scrum Masters. It is imperative to confirm that teams are self-sufficient and can function autonomously of their coaches.

Numerous organisations mistakenly believe that the responsibilities of an Agile coach and Scrum Master can be undertaken by a single person during an Agile transformation. Nevertheless, it is crucial to comprehend the diverse duties associated with each role and to have different persons execute them, as this can help develop an organisation during the transition phase and establish a firm basis for sustainable agility.

Join the Top 1% of Remote Developers and Designers

Works connects the top 1% of remote developers and designers with the leading brands and startups around the world. We focus on sophisticated, challenging tier-one projects which require highly skilled talent and problem solvers.
seasoned project manager reviewing remote software engineer's progress on software development project, hired from Works blog.join_marketplace.your_wayexperienced remote UI / UX designer working remotely at home while working on UI / UX & product design projects on Works blog.join_marketplace.freelance_jobs